Mk5 golf gti dsg vs manual

This is a special edition gti, developed by volkswagen individual. Dec 23, 2020 the new golf gti has an additional 45hp, which is only partially offset by a 76kg weight gain. The volkswagen golf mk5 codenamed typ 1k is a compact car, the fifth generation of the volkswagen golf and the successor to the volkswagen golf mk4, marketed in north america as the rabbit. Acceleration battle bmw 330ci vs vw golf mk5 gti 230. Maybe the issue is when comparing the dsg stronic to the manual audi s4 or gti or golf r etc, since those vwgroup manuals are all a bit on the clunky side, with long throws. It is running at about 300 bhp and is quite brutal when the turbo kicks in, especially when in auto. You just flick the gear stick to the left and it enters manual mode and you push the.

Dsg or manual vw golf r mk7 chat vwroc vw r owners club. Sharing the volkswagen group a5 pq35 platform, it debuted at the frankfurt motor show in october 2003 and went on sale in europe one month later. Sadly, googling mk5 dsg takes me to loads of threads discussing problems, in reality how reliable unreliable are they. Dsg v manual mk5 r32, which one r32oc vw golf r32, golf r. Seat ibiza overview manufacturer production 1984present assembly, body and chassis chronology predecessor the seat ibiza is a car manufactured by. Best thing to do is try both and see which you prefer. I have mkvi fixed typo gti with stage ii tuning and dsg, my friend has a new jetta with the new motor and stage i with manual tranny and he drove my gti last night and loves it and regrets getting the manual. The dsg is great for what it is definitely one of the bets autos around, but it is very clunky in lowspeedstopandgo driving, and is just not engaging or fun to drive for me. Dsg v manual mk5 r32, which one vw golf r32, golf r and.

I spend most of my commute in traffic on the m25 where an auto would be very nice, but. David zalstein and tony crawford tackle the question using one of the worlds best and most popular hothatches. Having owned my dbp 2003 mk4 golf r32 for 2 years and covering just 12k miles i decided to change to a newer steel grey 2005 mk5 r32. If you arent convinced about the speed of dsg vs manual check this youtube vid. Vw golf gti mk v specs, 060, quarter mile, lap times. I went for the dsg and find it and amazing gearbox. I personally prefer a manual box, dsg only takes about 0. It is equipped with 22540r18 pirelli pzero tyres on titanium colored alloy wheels. Im sure its been talked about loads but im quite new so thought id find out what people thought. Milltek nonres, silver stubby aerial, oc stickers, r32 seat inserts, more to follow. Drift king test golf gti dsg vs 6spd manual youtube. Im currently looking to buy a mk 5 gti or potentially an ed30. A compact mpv version of the car was produced as the golf. I was in the same boat a few years ago when buying a mk5 golf gti.

I have owned it for about 2 months now and love it. Dsg or manual, what would you do page 1 general gassing. Pdf vw golf mk5 owners manual 28 pages vw golf mk5 gti 2004. Jun 01, 2008 stock gti first up was the stock mk5 gti 2. However every time i got behind the wheel i felt letdown by the driving dynamics.

Vw volkswagen golf 1993 1999 repair service manual pdf 100. This was a massive gain over the previous generation model and put the golf gti back on top of the performance hatchback market. How you plan on using your gti, if you are going to modify it, and whether you want allout speed or a more involved driving experience are the things you need. The basic character of the engine is unchanged, which is to be expected given the mk8 uses a much evolved version of the mk5 s motor. Dsg vs manual transmission golf gti launch control.

Page 1 of 3 the mcd guide to mk4s vs mk5s posted in tutorials and guides. This dsg doesnt feel much like a manual when you climb behind the wheel and clock a familiar auto gearstick, complete with p, r, n and d markings. When i had my 2008 dsg gti the warranty on the dsg was extended to 10yr100,000 miles. Ive not yet driven a golf gti with dsg, but can only talk on my experiences driving my wifes audi a3 2.

Ive test driven cars with both transmissions and found myself really liking the dsg. Ive always loved the mk5 gti and now that theyve gotten so cheap, buying one is a no brainer for me, i just dont know what gearbox to go for. The most common engine problem in a 5th gen mk5 gti is. Copy dsg is a manual transmission, so you are looking at manual or manual on a golf, lol. Manual mode on dsg is way more fun and engaging than true manual. After writing my car off im now starting to look for a replacement. Looking at either a bora or a mk5 tdi 105 with dsg. Gone vw tiguan apr stage 1 stage 2 dsg tuned by hsp tuning. It was given the 230ps 169 kw226 hp edition 30 engine, instead of the 200ps 147 kw197 hp in the standard mk5 gti.

Of course this wasnt always the case with older vws. Club gti mk5 golf gti buying guide, 2003 2009 club gti. Can these still be remapped like the manuals to 150ish. Having had a mk2 golf gti many years ago followed by a mk4 golf v5 i enjoyed both of them. Feb 03, 2006 the mini cooper s vs the new mkv golf gti w dsg i have to admit i havent been a big fan of the most recent gti. The manual is the nocost option with a zillion cheaperout parts. How you plan on using your gti, if you are going to modify it, and whether you want allout speed or a more involved driving experience are the things you need to be asking yourself.

Volkswagen ags dsgs direct shift gearbox could be found in the mk5, mk6, and mk7 golf, gti. Went from a 6speed manual mini cooper s to a 6 speed dual clutch dsg volkswagen gti mk6. Mk5 gti dsg vs manual vask forum vw audi sportklub of nz. Havent heard of many problems vw build quality ia second to none. Bilekspressen tester dsg gearkasse vs manuelt gearkasseproduceret af brutto film. I work for the vw audi group and i can assure everyone who is starting to think it might be true that not even alonso could get a stock mk5 gti from 062 mph 0100 kph in anything less than 6. Then we had another one come in at the same time, so had two mk5 gti 2. So im in the market for a mk6 gti, and im having tons of trouble deciding which transmission to get. A vehicle equipped with a dsg transmission will have a traditional automaticstyle gear selector with a prnd indicator. I love my dsg because my gti is my commute car and hauler.

Is the dsg or manual golf gti, golf r, or gli better. There are several key points to consider when youre trying to decide between a vw gti dsg vs. Oct 29, 2009 i have always only ever owned manual cars, my r32 is manual but after having a play with a dsg thanks anakin. The 5 most common 5th gen mk5 volkswagen golf gti engine. Im currently planning on buy a golf gti, but as im in no hurry im waiting for the recaro seat option to be confirmed, but i will be most probably. Manual gives you a kind of driver engagement and enjoyment that simply cant be had with only 2 pedals. Im buying a new gti mk6 and i cant decide wether to go dsg or manual. I went dsg bc my track toy is manual, if i wanta get my shifting jollys off i just drive the track toy to work. Ive always owned manual cars and have currently got a mk4 gti and have just sold a manual e92 320d to make way for the mk5. Meeting on the traffic light golf gti mk5 vs mk6 gti difference dsg versus manual.

Does the golf gti edition 30 dsg have flappy paddles or is the change when in manual mode made via the gear stick in a touring car up and down sequential style. Wed obtained an example with the sixspeed dsg transmission to match the only gearbox available in the us version of the r32. The manual for me the gears were way too short, driving round town i was up and down the gears so much so opted for. The mcd guide to mk4s vs mk5s r32oc vw golf r32, golf r. Vw gti the dsg is nice dont get the manual youtube. I had a manual gti mk5 and loved it, but ive always. I wanted a manual and wasnt at all interested in dsg. The dsg is also 11 kilograms heavier than its kg manual counterpart and claims a higher average fuel consumption figure at 6.

Dsg is seamlessly and consistently much much faster. For all of the preaching and pontificating about why the manual transmission is the only real enthusiast choice for a gti, the fact remains that. Sep 29, 2020 with this new engine the mk5 golf gti could hit 100 kmh 62 mph in 7. For the rest of us, ill assume you know what the basic workings are and ill explore whathow the dsg mechatronic brain doesthinks.

Dsg is great in manual mode with auto upshift is mapped out, but the lag in auto mode isnt for me. Which would you say was best the dsg or the manual. Other than either the blue is fastest threads or whats best dsg or manual arguments this is probably the next most asked question. Ive always owned manual cars and have currently got a mk4 gti and have just sold a manual e92 320d to make way for the mk5, the mk4 will also be going in the next couple of months. The manual is definitely more engaging so therefore more fun for the people that need to shift gears. For a car like the gti, the manual is really a necessity to me. In 2006, the full mk5 line up launched in the usa and added the dsg transmission as an option on the sporty gti 2. Acceleration battle bmw 330ci vs vw golf mk5 gti 230 vs. The dsg box in the mk5 golf gti is an automatic and a clutchless manual. It is available in 6speed manual or an optional dsg gearbox.

Dsg is going to be more reliable, in general, than the manual. Manual vs dsg for long term reliability golfmk7 vw gti. Jun 23, 2020 this battle seems to be very boring, but if you really need fast car for less money, its quite simple. Every car ive owned has had a manual transmission, my favorite being my mk5 gli. Most sources seem to say the dsg is without a doubt the one to go for and youd be an eejit to go for the manual. While i think it is certainly a good idea that the 2015 volkswagen golf gti offers an automatic transmission option, there is absolutely. Dsg can get boring sometimes due to lack of involvement but its very affective and dsg farts are epic. Just after a general opinion whilst im trying to find my next pride and joy. Buying myself a golf gti mk5 in the next few weeks to commute in and cant decide between a manual or a dsg.